Sole Defendant In Benghazi Attacks Convicted Of Terrorism Charges — But Not Murder

An artist’s digest shows Ahmed Abu Khatallah being sworn in by Judge John Facciola during a U.S. District Court in Washington, D.C. The Libyan was indicted of masterminding a lethal conflict in Benghazi in 2012.

Jose Luis Magana/AP

hide caption

toggle caption

Jose Luis Magana/AP

An artist’s digest shows Ahmed Abu Khatallah being sworn in by Judge John Facciola during a U.S. District Court in Washington, D.C. The Libyan was indicted of masterminding a lethal conflict in Benghazi in 2012.

Jose Luis Magana/AP

Updated during 5:30 p.m. ET

More than 5 years after militants stormed a U.S. tactful devalue in Benghazi, murdering 4 Americans including a ambassador, a Libyan male charged with orchestrating a encircle has been convicted of terrorism charges. Yet in a outcome Tuesday, a jury clear Ahmed Abu Khatallah of a many critical charges opposite him, including murder.

Khatallah stays a solitary think charged for a lethal encircle on Sept. 11, 2012, when roughly 20 armed militants stormed a devalue in a fusillade of gunfire, grenades and trebuchet attacks. The Justice Department purported that “he conspired with others to conflict a facilities, kill U.S. citizens, destroy buildings and other property, and pillage materials, including documents, maps and computers containing supportive information.”

Still, after a hearing that lasted scarcely dual months, a jury returned a churned outcome on Khatallah, 46, anticipating him guilty on only 4 of a 18 charges lodged opposite him. While he still faces adult to 60 years in jail for crimes including swindling to yield element support for terrorism, he but avoided censure for a deaths of Ambassador Chris Stevens, Sean Smith, Tyrone Woods and Glen Doherty.

The Justice Department did not find a genocide chastisement in this trial.

“Today, a tiny magnitude of probity was meted out,” CIA Director Mike Pompeo pronounced in a summary to a organisation after a outcome Tuesday. “A sovereign jury convicted Ahmed Abu Khatallah for a apprehension he inflicted on a nationalistic organisation and women — from a State Department and CIA — in Benghazi, Libya on a night of Sep 11, 2012. It took comprehension to find him, soldiers to support in capturing him, law coercion to talk him, and a authorised organisation to put him away.”

“No tenure in jail will move a people back,” Pompeo added, lauding a memory of a organisation who died that night.

As NPR’s Carrie Johnson noted, a hearing betrothed to hinge partly on how a U.S. supervision rubbed a inquire of Khatallah after American army prisoner him in Libya in 2014.

“U.S. District Judge Christopher Cooper ruled that Khatallah was not mistreated by U.S. Special Operations Forces during their night constraint raid, brushing aside photos of a suspect with bruises and gashes on his face.

“The decider found that a process of interrogating Khatallah, starting with questions from a high-value-detainee comprehension team, holding a break, and afterwards renewing a sessions with a ‘clean’ organisation of FBI agents, upheld authorised muster. …

“The decider in Khatallah’s box also pronounced that holding 14 days to move a suspect to justice in a U.S. after transporting him, slowly, on a USS New York was reasonable given a unusual resources in a case.”

Once a hearing kicked off, prosecutors sought to execute Khatallah as consumed by blazing loathing for a U.S., job him a “stone-cold terrorist” during arguments in a courtroom. Relying on phone annals and worker videos, they presented him as a ringleader, rather than a male directly pulling a trigger.

Or, as one prosecutor put it: “You will not hear that he illuminated a compare or dismissed a mortar. It does not matter.”

The defense, for a part, countered by observant that Khatallah was merely being demonized by organisation and that in a deficiency of constrained evidence, a charge was simply personification to jurors’ emotions. Defense attorneys also expel doubt on a prosecution’s witnesses, observant a informants could not be devoted since they were paid — $7 million, in a box of one Libyan witness.

Outside a courtroom, a conflict in Benghazi has valid scarcely as contentious.

Since scarcely a impulse that lethal eventuality ended, a conflict in Benghazi has been a domestic flashpoint in a U.S. It has been an emanate in dual presidential elections, with Republicans criticizing how a Obama administration — including then-Secretary of State Hillary Clinton — rubbed a assault and a aftermath.

GOP lawmakers in a House also led an in-depth review into a attack, that lasted roughly dual years and found that a Obama administration had been inattentive in a face of comprehension warnings and delayed in a response.