Share

Reaction To Cosby Case

Bill Cosby looks on as orator Andrew Wyatt triumphantly raises his fist outward a Montgomery County Courthouse in Norristown, Pa., on Saturday. Cosby’s authorised and broadside group treated a mistrial as a victory, yet prosecutors immediately pronounced they devise to retry a case.

Matt Rourke/AP


hide caption

toggle caption

Matt Rourke/AP

Bill Cosby looks on as orator Andrew Wyatt triumphantly raises his fist outward a Montgomery County Courthouse in Norristown, Pa., on Saturday. Cosby’s authorised and broadside group treated a mistrial as a victory, yet prosecutors immediately pronounced they devise to retry a case.

Matt Rourke/AP

Updated during 1:05 p.m. ET

The decider in a passionate attack box of comedian Bill Cosby has announced a mistrial. After several days of deliberations, a jury could not come to a unanimous agreement on either Cosby unperceiving and molested Andrea Constand, a former worker of Temple University, during his home nearby Philadelphia in 2004.

But this does not meant an finish to a high-profile case: Prosecutors immediately pronounced they will retry a case.

Cosby, 79, stays charged with 3 second-degree transgression depends of aggravated faulty assault, and any count carries a smallest judgment of 5 years in prison. All told, if found guilty, Cosby could spend a rest of his life in prison.

“I remind everybody that this is not clearance or victory,” Montgomery County Judge Steven T.O’Neill pronounced Saturday. “A mistrial is merely a probity complement during work.”

Nevertheless, Cosby’s authorised and broadside group emerged onto a front stairs of a courtroom triumphant.

“Justice is alive in Montgomery County,” Cosby’s attorney, Brian McMonagle, pronounced with his customer station silently behind him. “We wanted an acquittal, though like a Rolling Stones strain says, we can’t always get what we want; infrequently we get what we need.”

And in a sardonic matter review aloud by a representative, Cosby’s wife, Camille, called a a district profession “heinously and exploitatively ambitious” and a decider “overtly and arrogantly collaborating” with him — among other allegations.

Asked after either he believes Saturday’s mistrial represents a feat for Cosby, orator Andrew Wyatt said: “I do. we consider a DA — he has to contend he’s going to retry. But since keep costing these adults millions of dollars?”

Meanwhile, Constand’s attorneys are “confident that these record have given a voice to a many victims who felt unable and silenced,” they pronounced in a statement.

“We praise those prosecutors,” they continued, “who lifted recognition that one of a hallmarks of drug associated passionate assaults is a impact a drug has on a victim’s memory and ability to remember and were nonetheless peaceful to benefaction this justification to a jury.”

Andrea Constand is “entitled to a outcome in this case,” District Attorney Kevin Steele pronounced during a news discussion after Saturday. “We will pull brazen to try to get probity done.”

He says that legally, he has 365 days to retry a box though that he hopes to “push it along” earlier than that.

“You can’t put a cost tab on justice,” Steele said, when asked by reporters about a cost of a trial. “If we do, you’re observant if someone is rich or famous, they don’t merit a same arrange of probity as everybody else.”

How a box unfolded

Constand is not a usually lady who says Cosby raped or intimately assaulted her. Dozens of women have come brazen over a past several years, with stories that relate one another. But in many of those cases, a government of stipulations had lapsed by a time a women told their stories publicly. Constand’s box was a exception.

She reported a crime to military in 2005 and filed a polite fit opposite Cosby after prosecutors declined to press charges. A decade later, as some-more and some-more women stepped brazen with accounts of assault, prosecutors took a second demeanour during a allegations and this time, filed rapist charges.

Prosecutors argued that Cosby unperceiving Constand to impair her so he could attack her. They cited Cosby’s possess statements that he gave her pills and overwhelmed her intimately and called another charge to a mount to make a box that Cosby had a settlement of drugging and assaulting women.

Cosby’s invulnerability group questioned Constand’s credibility, indicating to inconsistencies in her accounts to a police, and argued that a 2004 confront was consensual and “romantic.”

The charge took 5 days to benefaction their case; a defense, reduction than a day. Cosby did not attest in his possess defense.

Cosby’s wife, Camille, assimilated him in a courtroom as his invulnerability group presented a case. Supporters and well-wishers also collected outward a courthouse; during times during a trial, Cosby “appeared in good spirits” as he spoke to and saluted his fans, The Associated Press reports.

Jury deliberations started Monday afternoon. As a days passed, a jury regularly asked to rehear portions of a testimony.

Cosby Jury Deadlocks; Judge Orders Further Deliberations

On Thursday, after some-more than 30 hours of deliberations, a members of a jury told a decider they were unresolved and could not strech a unanimous consensus. The decider systematic them to try again, giving them instructions meant to motivate an uncertain jury to come to a conclusion.

By a time a mistrial was announced Saturday, a tired jurors had spent some-more than 50 hours in deliberations.

A flourishing call of allegations

For decades, Cosby’s open picture seemed not only untarnished, though untarnishable. He was a star of a extravagantly renouned The Cosby Show and a successful stand-up comic. Genial, avuncular, beloved: He was America’s dad.

As NPR’s Gene Demby has written, Cosby was a black personality who served not only as a secular and informative envoy to white America, though also as a financial devotee of black America.

When What Was Good For Bill Cosby Was Good For Black America

“Black colleges and impending black college students were buoyed by his philanthropy, while his collections of black art graced critical museums,” Gene writes. “Even before his late-career spin as black America’s dignified scold, Cosby had spent decades disposition into his renouned picture as a consanguine figure to accelerate his change as a paternalistic one.”

Cosby presented himself as a arrange of dignified personality and disciple for responsibility: His argumentative “pound cake” debate excoriated bad black Americans for what he described as stupidity and bad parenting.

In Philadelphia, where he grew up, Cosby was a hometown hero. “Cosby gave income to a city, and whenever he could, his time,” Annette John-Hall reported for NPR. “In a early 2000s, he participated in ‘callback sessions’ with open housing residents in North Philadelphia, where they would speak about education, attack and teen pregnancy, among other issues.”

For Many Philadelphia Residents, Bill Cosby Is Still Their 'Hometown Boy'

In short, Cosby’s name was synonymous with village leadership, black success, sitcom fatherhood, confidant sweaters and Jell-O ads.

But a array of allegations of rape and seduction began swirling around a corner of that reputation. In 2000, a lady indicted Cosby of groping her. Then Constand’s allegations drew courtesy in 2005.

Constand’s story led another lady to step forward, revelation a Today uncover that Cosby unperceiving and assaulted her in a 1970s. Then another woman. Then another.

Cosby regularly and vehemently denied any wrongdoing. Almost a decade passed, and no rapist charges were filed. Cosby’s bequest and career survived — by early 2014, Gawker described a allegations as “effectively forgotten.”

Then, in a tumble of 2014, comedian Hannibal Buress mentioned a allegations in a set. He pronounced he was angry by Cosby’s “smug” persona: ” ‘Pull your pants up, black people. we was on TV in a ’80s. we can speak down to we since we had a successful sitcom.’ Yeah, though we raped women, Bill Cosby. … Brings we down a integrate notches.”

“You leave here and Google ‘Bill Cosby rape,’ ” Buress told a audience. “It’s not funny. That s*** has some-more formula than Hannibal Buress.”

The bit went viral, and unexpected Cosby’s purported assaults were behind in a news. As in 2005 and 2006, some-more women stepped brazen with stories of assault.

But this time, a call of allegations didn’t stop, and few people seemed prone to forget and pierce on.

NPR’s Scott Simon asked Cosby to directly residence a allegations in a Nov 2014 interview. Cosby responded with an attention-grabbing array of silences.

In NPR Interview, Bill Cosby Declines To Discuss Assault Allegations

The Associated Press went to justice to get entrance to a formerly hermetic deposition from Constand’s polite fit opposite Cosby. The handle use expelled a request — in that Cosby certified that he performed quaaludes, a sedative, with a vigilant of giving a drug to women he wanted to have sex with.

Then 35 women told their stories to New York magazine. Side by side, a stories showed a same themes again and again: Women who saw Cosby as a mentor, a father figure or an dignified celebrity. A splash or a pill. Helplessness or fear or a night wholly mislaid to memory. Years of silence.

Cosby has continued, by his representatives, to repudiate that he committed any passionate assaults — revelation to infidelity though progressing that all a passionate hit was consensual.