Share

Mexico Worries That A New Border Wall Will Worsen Flooding

A perspective from a International overpass between Presidio, Texas and Ojinaga, Mexico shows a flooded check indicate between a dual cities on Sept. 17, 2008. A wharf pennyless and H2O from a Rio Grande flooded tools of a city with 10 feet of water.

Walt Frerck/AP


hide caption

toggle caption

Walt Frerck/AP

A perspective from a International overpass between Presidio, Texas and Ojinaga, Mexico shows a flooded check indicate between a dual cities on Sept. 17, 2008. A wharf pennyless and H2O from a Rio Grande flooded tools of a city with 10 feet of water.

Walt Frerck/AP

As a White House pushes Congress to account President Trump’s U.S.-Mexico limit wall, a new fold has emerged that could stymie tools of a large project.

Mexican engineers trust construction of a limit separator competence violate a 47-year-old covenant ruling a common waters of a Rio Grande. If Mexico protests, a predestine of a wall could finish adult in an ubiquitous court.

Antonio Rascón, arch Mexican operative on a International Boundary and Water Commission, pronounced in an talk with NPR that some limit wall proposals he’s seen would violate a treaty, and that Mexico would not mount for that.

Antonio Rascón, arch operative of a Mexican territory of International Boundary and Water Commission, says a U.S. has already built scarcely 700 miles of confidence blockade and Mexico has consistently against it.

John Burnett/NPR


hide caption

toggle caption

John Burnett/NPR

Antonio Rascón, arch operative of a Mexican territory of International Boundary and Water Commission, says a U.S. has already built scarcely 700 miles of confidence blockade and Mexico has consistently against it.

John Burnett/NPR

“A petrify wall that blocks trans-border H2O transformation is a sum obstruction. If they devise that form of project, we will conflict it,” he pronounced in his initial open comments on a limit wall.

The U.S. Department of Homeland Security has not nonetheless finalized what a new wall would demeanour like, or precisely where it would go. But some of a initial schematics uncover it could be as high as 30 feet and done of plain concrete.

Mexico is examination with flourishing alarm as Homeland Security moves brazen with a devise to dramatically extend a limit separator that already has caused inauspicious flooding.

While Congress debates either to embody appropriation in a refuge spending plan, a dialect has solicited bids for prototypes. Trump also pronounced he would continue to ask Mexico to compensate for a wall, though Mexican President Enrique Peña Nieto has pronounced regularly that he has no skeleton to feet a bill.

The 1970 Boundary Treaty lays out a accurate limit between a U.S. and Mexico, and sets manners for a riverside regions. The covenant states both U.S. and Mexican officials on a International Boundary and Water Commission, or IBWC, must agree if one side wants to build any structure that would impact a upsurge of a Rio Grande or a floodwaters.

The U.S. already has built scarcely 700 miles of confidence fence, and Mexico has consistently against it. After Mexico protested a progressing blockade construction, a U.S. done some pattern modifications, though a devise went brazen over Mexico’s objections.

Borderland Trump Supporters Welcome A Wall In Their Own Backyard

“For us, we are not in agreement with construction of a wall in a floodplain that affects a trans-border upsurge of water,” Rascón said.In general, we have been angry about a blockade given 1992. We’re articulate 25 years. That’s when they consecrated a initial blockade in San Diego, and it’s been advancing and advancing.”

The International Boundary and Water Commission, located in Juarez, Mexico, and El Paso, Texas, has attempted to solve differences sensitively with professionalism and tact in a 128 years of existence. But a confidant devise for Trump’s wall is straining that cross-border collegiality.

Steven Mumme, a domestic scholarship highbrow during Colorado State University who has complicated U.S.-Mexico H2O tact for scarcely 40 years, predicts a showdown is coming.

Southern Border Wall: Campaign Slogan Meets Reality

“This is ostensible to go brazen on a binational, mild basis, and that is not happening,” Mumme said. “Mexico reporting a covenant right underneath a 1970 Boundary Treaty is some-more approaching than ever since of a heightened nationalism and a indignation about a United States fence/wall project.”

To criticism a limit wall, Mexican officials on a range and H2O elect would initial board a grave censure with their reflection opposite a stream in El Paso. If they don’t solve a dispute, a matter goes to a State Department and a Mexican equivalent, and finally, to settlement before a universe court.

Mumme says concerns over floods on a limit are well-founded. He and other stream hydraulics experts indicate out that a wall built in a floodplain acts like a dam. During torrential rains, these obstructions inhibit H2O and wear flooding.

“It can occur, and substantially will occur, if we create, in effect, a array of small dams along one side of a river,” Mumme said. “We have a history. We know they occur.”

Blocked by a walking fence, floodwaters from Headquarters Wash nearby Lukeville, Ariz., flowed along a blockade and into a Mexican Port of Entry in Sonoyta, Sonora in 2008.

National Park Service


hide caption

toggle caption

National Park Service

Blocked by a walking fence, floodwaters from Headquarters Wash nearby Lukeville, Ariz., flowed along a blockade and into a Mexican Port of Entry in Sonoyta, Sonora in 2008.

National Park Service

Over a past 9 years, steel fencing has clogged with waste along a Arizona limit during a summer stormy season. Floodwaters shop-worn Organ Pipe Cactus National Monument in 2008 and coursed by a Lukeville, Ariz., pier of entry.

In a twin cities of Nogales in a U.S. and Mexico, distracted floodwaters killed dual people, cleared cars away, collapsed a territory of a fence, and caused millions in indemnification in apart events in 2008 and 2014.

“It only walled adult a water,” Mumme said, “dammed adult a water.”

Even worse flooding is approaching if a wall is built in a floodplain of a Rio Grande Valley of Texas. Homeland Security has prolonged wanted to put a blockade along a stream in Starr County, Texas — a favorite channel mark for smugglers of drugs and people.

“I know from my knowledge that was a place where we suspicion a separator done sense,” Border Patrol Chief Ron Vitiello pronounced recently in a debate in San Antonio. He was hire arch of a Border Patrol in Rio Grande City when a initial blockade devise was considered.

Two things blocked execution of a limit blockade in Starr County: Congressional appropriation ran out, and a Mexican side of a range and H2O elect resisted a blockade in a floodplain.

Today, Starr County is one of a initial places on a 2,000-mile limit where Trump’s wall is approaching to resume. Everything is prepared to go: The supervision has been seizing land along a stream by venerable domain, and there are already blueprints for where to build about 10 miles of fence.

Vitiello insists a U.S. will not big-foot their Mexican neighbors.

“If we go brazen inside of a floodplain, afterwards it will approve with a shortcoming underneath a treaty,” he said.

Locals are not comforted by a government’s assurances. Rio Grande City — a county chair of Starr County — is one of 3 designed sites for a limit wall. Two city officials pronounced a progressing designed blockade would have been located within 100 yards of a sluggish, greenish Rio Grande.

Alberto Perez, Rio Grande City manager (left), and Gilbert Millan, a city’s formulation director, travel along a riverbank to uncover how tighten a progressing designed blockade would be located subsequent to a water.

John Burnett/NPR


hide caption

toggle caption

John Burnett/NPR

Alberto Perez, Rio Grande City manager (left), and Gilbert Millan, a city’s formulation director, travel along a riverbank to uncover how tighten a progressing designed blockade would be located subsequent to a water.

John Burnett/NPR

They’re fearful a wall would forestall a city from scrupulously removal during a whirly floating in from a Gulf of Mexico, reduction than a hundred miles away.

“The drainage complement would apparently be impacted due to a boring of waste from H2O entrance behind to a riverbanks,” Planning Director Gilbert Millan said.

City Manager Albert Perez said: “Or it competence finish adult knocking down a wall since a water’s gotta get out of here somehow. And there’s nowhere for that H2O to go when we have those floods.”

At one point, a U.S. territory of a range and H2O elect sided with disturbed city officials. Back in 2007, when a Starr County limit blockade was initial proposed, U.S. stream engineers assimilated their Mexican counterparts in energetically hostile it.

Then a U.S. officials flipped 180 degrees.

“And in early 2012, a U.S. territory of IBWC pronounced we respectfully remonstrate with a Mexican counterparts and we approve these walls going up,” says Scott Nicol, co-chairman of a Rio Grande Valley Sierra Club.

Nicol obtained, by open annals requests, thousands of sovereign papers that he common with NPR. What they uncover is that a U.S. territory of a elect altered a position after being presented with a new devise for a Starr County separator consecrated by Homeland Security.

In an email to NPR, U.S. Commissioner Edward Drusina wrote: “After clever care of a state-of-the-art hydraulic indication … we resolved there was no poignant reason to intent to Homeland Security move with a construction of a fence.”

Others, including Mexico’s arch stream operative Rascón, still aren’t convinced.

“We’ve seen lots of vigour by Homeland Security so that this devise moves forward,” Rascón said. “But a kind of wall they’re formulation would have extreme effects on trans-border H2O flows.”