Share

In The Age Of Digital Medicine, The Humble Reflex Hammer Hangs On

The good aged involuntary produce (like this Taylor model) competence seem like an old-fashioned medical device, though a purpose in diagnosing illness is still as critical as ever.

Meredith Rizzo/NPR


hide caption

toggle caption

Meredith Rizzo/NPR

The good aged involuntary produce (like this Taylor model) competence seem like an old-fashioned medical device, though a purpose in diagnosing illness is still as critical as ever.

Meredith Rizzo/NPR

Receiving a diagnosis in 2017 — during slightest one done during a medical core given with a latest clinical gadgetry — competence embody a indicate that divides your physique into a bread fritter of high-resolution digital slices. Your DNA competence be fed by a gene sequencer that spits out your mortal formula in a matter of hours. Even your smartphone competence shortly be used to expose health problems.

Yet scarcely 130 years given a pregnancy — after decades of scholarship has mapped out a neuronal pathways — a elementary doorknob of rubber with a steel hoop stays one of medicine’s many essential tools. I’m referring to a cheap, portable, easy-to-use involuntary hammer.

This artless device can be useful in diagnosing shaken and robust disorders, and in last possibly a patient’s pathology lies in a mind or elsewhere in a body. It can also assistance diminish medical spending by preventing unnecessary, mostly dear testing. Yet like so many vital medical and systematic discoveries, a involuntary produce has common origins, in this case: a groundwork of a Viennese hotel.

The motel was run by a father of Leopold Auenbrugger, an 18th century alloy who is deliberate to be among a founders of complicated medicine. To sign how many booze was left for customers, hotel employees would bump casks with their hands and listen for a lifeless whack or vale tympany. Auenbrugger satisfied that a same technique — now called “percussing” — could be practical to a tellurian torso to, say, establish how many liquid had built adult around a infirm heart. He wrote as many in his 1761 paper New invention to detect diseases dark low within a chest.

Leopold Auenbrugger (here with his wife, Marianne) is regarded as one of a founders of complicated medicine, carrying practical a thought of detecting illness by sound.

Wellcome Library, London


hide caption

toggle caption

Wellcome Library, London

Leopold Auenbrugger (here with his wife, Marianne) is regarded as one of a founders of complicated medicine, carrying practical a thought of detecting illness by sound.

Wellcome Library, London

Relflex produce warfare

Thought to be some-more accurate than a tellurian hand, it wasn’t prolonged before percussion hammers were being designed to some-more precisely diagnose disease. Competition ensued.

Scottish medicine Sir David Barry’s model, expelled in a 1820s, was a first. German alloy Max A. Wintrich’s came shortly after and was some-more popular, though was not though a critics: “[Wintrich’s hammer] is untimely to hold, it is firm … it compulsory preparation to use it, and even afterwards it does not perform a purposes,” a opposition contriver commented.

As neurologist Dr. Douglas J. Lanksa wrote in a 1989 paper on a many forms of involuntary hammers, “Some were T-shaped or L-shaped, others resembled conflict axes, tomahawks, or even sorcery wands.” He adds that no element was off limits: wood, ebony, whale bone, brass, lead, even “velvet-covered worsted” (a form of yarn).

As percussion produce crusade waged on, doctors and scientists were also commencement to know a judgment of reflexes, or involuntary, near-immediate responses to stimuli that start before any feeling information reaches a brain. Muscular jerks. Blinking. Sneezing. Gagging. All of these are involuntary feedback loops between feeling and engine neurons that assistance us navigate a sourroundings and strengthen us from danger.

In 1875, German neurologists Drs. Heinrich Erb and Carl Friedrich Otto Westphal were among a initial to comprehend that eliciting a involuntary by briskly drumming a tendons of vital muscles competence be useful. They felt a knee jerk — or “patellar-tendon” involuntary — in sold could assistance consider haughtiness function.

Anton Wintrich introduced this percussion produce indication in 1841.

Wellcome Library, London


hide caption

toggle caption

Wellcome Library, London

Anton Wintrich introduced this percussion produce indication in 1841.

Wellcome Library, London

Hammers privately matched to exam reflexes were shortly developed, a initial of that had a now classical figure we’re accustomed to — a skinny steel hoop with a triangular rubber head. Designed by American medicine John Madison Taylor in Philadelphia in 1888 — and mutated ever given by many — a elementary device was complicated adequate to bleed reflexes, and had turn edges to palliate impact. An entrance turn indication runs only $2.25 on Amazon.

The Krauss hammer, grown by German-American medicine William Christopher Krauss, was designed around a same time. It had dual dull heads: a vast one for knees and a smaller one for biceps. Dr. Ernst L.O. Trömner’s did too, though it also slim to a skinny finish to consider skin reflexes. There were also a Queen Square hammer, a Babinski hammer, a Buck produce and a Berliner hammer. The Stookey produce flaunted a camel hair brush to get a improved clarity of hold sensation. The list goes on.

Past to present

Daniella C. Sisniega is a third year medical tyro during a Boston University School of Medicine. Last month during a American Academy of Neurology’s annual meeting, she presented a print explicating a involuntary hammer’s past.

“I’m preoccupied by how a involuntary produce started out as a percussion hammer, though was [then] blending to bleed reflexes and has been in any neurologist’s apparatus box ever since,” she told NPR. “I also did not know that a small rubber triangle was a initial involuntary hammer. we feel like we owe it an apology!”

You Can Monitor Heart Rhythm With A Smartphone, But Should You?

Sisniega jokes about a muted peculiarity of a inexpensive Taylors.

“The small pickaxe is enclosed in a pack everybody receives when they enter medical school,” she recalls. “The rubber is inexpensive and really light, while a other hammers are heavier on a conduct so that we can use a ‘swing’ of a produce as against to a strength of a strike to exam a reflex.”

While attending a AAN discussion myself, we asked mixed sclerosis consultant Dr. Stephen Krieger about a purpose of a involuntary produce in complicated medical diagnosis.

“We could disagree about a nuances of a produce — a Queens Square, a Tomahawk, cosmetic handle, steel handle, weighted, stretchable or firm — though a produce itself is always in a hand. Reflexes tell a story of neurologic diseases of all sorts,” he says.

Krieger explains how disorders of a brain, like a cadence or mind tumor, outcome in hyperactive reflexes, while conditions inspiring muscles and marginal nerves customarily outcome in reduced or self-existent reflexes. Reduced reflexes are, for example, a common sign of behind pain due to degenerative hoop disease.

Dr. Andrew Wilner, an partner highbrow of neurology during a Mayo Clinic, recounted a story of one of his patients, who had behind pain, debility and insensibility of a legs. Wilner was disposition toward a diagnosis of possibly Guillain-Barre Syndrome (GBS) — an autoimmune commotion of marginal nerves — or a myelopathy, an damage of some kind to a spinal cord. Both conditions can lead to medical emergencies, though any requires drastically opposite treatment.

Maybe You Should Skip That Annual Physical

“The involuntary produce was arguably a many critical apparatus in squeezing down a differential diagnosis,” he says. “Had we found discontinued or absent low tendon reflexes, GBS would have been some-more likely. As it incited out, a studious had sprightly pathological knee jerks, indicating to a lesion in a mind or spinal cord.”

Based on these findings, Wilner systematic an imaging investigate of a patient’s spinal cord, where a lesion was found — as against to posterior a dear tests concerned in a GBS diagnosis.

Wilner feels that a elementary art of interviewing and examining a studious can get overshadowed by a innumerable new evidence technologies. When it comes to clinical tools, he feels, infrequently elementary is better.

“Technology is glorious,” admits Krieger, “and [it] will learn us things about patients that we could never have famous or imagined. But a simple, elegant, inexpensive roughly undignified pitch of a involuntary produce has a cost/benefit ratio that we consider no modernized record will expected ever match.”

Bret Stetka is a author formed in New York and an editorial executive during Medscape. His work has seemed in Wired and Scientific American, and on The Atlantic.com. He graduated from a University of Virginia School of Medicine in 2005. He’s also on Twitter: @BretStetka