Share

Does Baby Powder Cause Cancer? A Jury Says Yes. Scientists Aren’t So Sure

A California jury awarded a lady $417 million in a box opposite Johnson Johnson. The lady claimed that her use of Johnson’s Baby Powder led to depot ovarian cancer. Scientists remonstrate on how clever a couple there is between talc and ovarian cancer.

Frederic J. Brown/AFP/Getty Images


hide caption

toggle caption

Frederic J. Brown/AFP/Getty Images

A California jury awarded a lady $417 million in a box opposite Johnson Johnson. The lady claimed that her use of Johnson’s Baby Powder led to depot ovarian cancer. Scientists remonstrate on how clever a couple there is between talc and ovarian cancer.

Frederic J. Brown/AFP/Getty Images

If you’re a woman, there’s a good possibility you’ve used Johnson’s Baby Powder during some point. It smells good, and it can keep we dry.

But is it dangerous?

Dr. Daniel Cramer says yes. He’s a highbrow of obstetrics and gynecology during Brigham and Women’s Hospital in Boston. He says talc — a vegetable in talcum powder — can means ovarian cancer.

“Overall, women competence boost their risk in ubiquitous by about 33 percent by regulating talc in their hygiene,” Cramer says.

On Monday, a California jury awarded Eva Echeverria $417 million in a box opposite Johnson Johnson. Echeverria, who is pang from depot ovarian cancer, claimed it was caused by Johnson’s Baby Powder, that she used on her perineum for decades.

Hers wasn’t a initial jury endowment opposite a company. And thousands some-more cases are pending.

It has non-stop a long-simmering doubt about either talcum powder used in a genital area can means cancer.

Cramer, who has served as a paid consultant on several ovarian cancer cases opposite Johnson Johnson, published one of a initial studies observant an organisation between talc and ovarian cancer in 1982.

“This story goes behind a long, prolonged way, behind into a ’70s when people remarkable that ovarian cancer had many similarities to asbestos exposure,” he says. “Meanwhile another organisation in England found talc that was deeply embedded in ovaries and pronounced there competence be a story here.”

In fact, talc is a vegetable that is infrequently mined alongside asbestos. And asbestos, a famous carcinogen, was found in a past in some talc products.

After his initial investigate on a talc-cancer association, Cramer followed adult with an essay in 1985 job on companies like Johnson Johnson to put warning labels on their talcum powder products.

Johnson Johnson declined to be interviewed for this story. The organisation pronounced in a matter that it skeleton to interest a California verdict.

“We are guided by a science, that supports a reserve of Johnson’s Baby Powder,” wrote organisation mouthpiece Carol Goodrich in a statement. “In April, a National Cancer Institute’s Physician Data Query Editorial Board wrote, ‘The weight of justification does not support an organisation between perineal talc bearing and an increasing risk of ovarian cancer.’ We are scheming for additional trials in a U.S., and we will continue to urge a reserve of Johnson’s Baby Powder.”

Some researchers determine that a couple between talc and ovarian cancer isn’t all that clear.

The International Agency for Research on Cancer, partial of a World Health Organization, in 2010 called talc a probable carcinogen.

“It’s not explanation positive,” says Joellen Schildkraut, a highbrow of open health during a University of Virginia. “These studies are suggestive. They support a idea.”

Her investigate shows there’s a stronger couple between talc and ovarian cancer among African-American women than there is among white women. But to her, even that couple isn’t proof.

“I would not call this conclusive. It’s unchanging with other reports in a past. It’s revealing of a stronger association, though it is not conclusive,” she says.

There are theories about how talcum powder could means cancer. If women put it on their underwear or on delicate products, it could get into their reproductive system. Then, talc particles could make their approach to a ovaries — investigate has already shown that can happen, and talc has been found in ovarian tumors. The talc could afterwards means exasperation and inflammation that, over time, could lead to cancer.

“We can contend that it is compared with an increasing risk [of cancer],” says Shelley Tworoger, a cancer epidemiologist during a Moffitt Cancer Center in Tampa, Fla. “And there are biologic mechanisms by that we consider that talc could indeed impact ovarian cancer. But we would stop brief of observant that it indispensably causes ovarian cancer.”

But she says there’s positively adequate information out there to beam women.

“Why use it?” she says. “I don’t know if we should contend this or not, though … because not only be protected and not use it?”